The critical thinking community this website is sponsored by the foundation for critical thinking and the center for critical thinking. Peter facione and noreen facione have developed the fourlevel holistic critical thinking scoring rubric to assess the critical thinking skills and some of the dispositions identified by the delphi project as these skills are demonstrated by by students in essays, projects, presentations, clinical practices, and such. Objectives excellent 4 proficient 3 developing 2 beginning 1 not evident 0 identify, interpret, and evaluate issueproblem. Framing language this rubric is designed to be transdisciplinary, reflecting the recognition that success in all disciplines requires habits o f inquiry and. Critical thinking ethical reasoning communication american accounting association second annual conference on teaching and learning in accounting august 1, 2009 new york susan k. Holistic critical thinking scoring rubric temple university. Identify student learning outcomes for critical thinking. Two aacu websites contain possible rubric models in disciplinespecific. Critical thinking rubric objectives level 5 level 4 level 3 level 2 level 1 conceptualize identifies basic and complex issues, clearly and effectively identifies basic issues, clearly and effectively. Provides some consideration of assumptions and their implications. The primary purpose of a ge area a3 course is to build a specific toolset that allows students to rigorously explore reasoning and its presentation. Implementation exemplary interpretation and evaluation of information, facts, data, images andor graphics. Critical thinking rubric evaluation criteria outcomes advanced 4.
Why you can pass tests and still fail in the real world today, assessment focuses on the regurgitation of memorized informationinstead of developing 21stcentury skills, all were really doing is using assessment to rank and classify students. This rubric is designed to be transdisciplinary, reflecting the recognition that success in all disciplines requires habits of inquiry and analysis that share common attributes. Washington state university critical thinking project. Critical thinking is not one thing, but is demonstrated uniquely in each context. Critical thinking value rubric association of american. The scoring rubric is used as a formative assessment, providing detailed. The critical thinking rubric presented in this ctl bulletin was created to facilitate embedded assessment of goal 2 of the gened program. The rubric is made up of a set of attributes that are common to creative thinking across disciplines. Position is generally clear, although gaps may exist. Analyzes the issue with a clear sense of scope and context, including an assessment of.
To reach a judicious, purposive judgment a good critical thinker engages in analysis, interpretation, evaluation, inference, explanation, and metacognitive selfregulation. Demonstrate spirituality as a way of living in relationship with self, others, society, cosmos, and god. Identifies and explains the issue question problem the issue question problem is clearly and eloquently defined the scope of the issue. Individuals and groups use critical thinking in problem solving and decision making. Check out this two page document defining the 4 cs and a movie giving you even more of an explanation.
Critical theory and adult learning packet zip file containing 12 pdfs the skillful teacher workshop packet. It provides resources such as fulltext articles and teaching materials. Microsoft innovative learning this website contains some powerful rubrics for assessing the 21st century skills. Critical and creative thinking in the highereducation classroom eric mazur. Two rubrics for critical thinking assessment radford university. The link will bring you to a pdf file with critical thinking rubrics you can use tomorrow for any grade level. This four level rubric treats critical thinking as a set of cognitive skills supported by certain personal dispositions. Selecting and using information to investigate a point of view or conclusion. Critical and creative thinking is a concept in which one applies logical principles, after much inquiry and analysis, to solve problems in with.
A rubric is a learning and assessment tool that articulates the expectations for assignments and performance tasks by listing criteria, and for each criteria, describing levels of quality andrade, 2000. Critical thinking is a habit of mind characterized by the comprehensive exploration of issues, ideas, artifacts, and events before accepting or formulating an opinion or conclusion. Critical thinking scoring rubric university of southern maine. It is a critical thinking supplement to any textbook or course. Below are printable pdf files of the original wsu critical thinking rubric along with sample adaptations from entomology, math, and metaphysics. This rubric will help assess a students thinking and reasoning skills. Adapted from the aacu leap rubrics, the bases of competence skills, and the university of guelph learning outcomes. Proficiency in critical thinking at the a3 level is demonstrated by the identification, analysis, evaluation, and presentation of. For more background about the wsu critical thinking project, visit the project history page. Assignments that cut across presentation mode might be e specially useful in some fields. Holistic critical thinking scoring rubric in english pdf. The use of these competencies across the curriculum will ensure that critical thinking is fostered in the teaching of any subject to all students at every grade level.
Show your rating scale beginning on the left with the highest. Fails to justify own opinion or hypothesis is unclear or simplistic. Using the holistic critical thinking scoring rubric to. Justifies own position without addressing other views or does so superficially. Presents own position, which includes some original thinking, though inconsistently. In practice, this will mean that not every performance area in each of the rubrics will be necessary in every lesson, unit, or assessment. Rubrics for assessmenton this page are the approved keystone writing rubrics as well as grouping, management, and an oral presentation rubric i and ii that also includes rubrics for research papers, critical thinking, peer work and collaboration, as well as a project design rubric for staff to evaluate necessary components of their pbl projects. The creative thinking value rubric is intended to help faculty assess creative think ing in a broad range of transdisciplinary or interdisciplinary work samples or collections of work.
A rubric is a scoring guide used to evaluate performance, a product, or a project. Framing language this rubric is designed to be transdisciplinary, reflecting the recognition that success in all disciplines requires habits o f inquiry and analysis that share common attributes. Ccss ela aligned critical thinking opportunity at phases of a project below standard approaching standard at standard above standard launching the project. If the file has been modified from its original state, some details may not fully reflect the modified file. A critical thinking rubric 35 rubric based on the critical thinking framework. Noreen facione and i developed the holistic critical thinking scoring rubric in 1994 in response to requests for a tool which a could be used to evaluate a variety of educational work products including essays, presentations, and demonstrations, and b works as both a pedagogical device to guide people to know what critical thinking is as. It is best used in conjunction with the analytic thinking guide. Identifies, summarizes, and appropriately formulates the issue e. It is expected that graduates of clarke college will be able to. Critical thinking value rubric association of american colleges.
Written material demonstrates knowledge of fact, theories, methods, procedures. Writers workshop mentor text list writers workshop standards chart writers workshop organizational tools writers workshop unit overview writers workshop goal setting chart for studentled outcomes you can fin. Critical thinking resources university of tennessee at. Critical thinking criteria for evaluating online discussion. This rubric is designed for use with many different types of assignments and the suggestions here are not an exhaustive list of possibilities. Students apply a rational and methodical approach to problem solving based on use of appropriate evidence. This rubric is designed to be transdisciplinary, reflecting the recognition that success in all disciplines requires habits of inquiry and analysis that share common. The essence of critical thinking concepts and tools distilled into a 20page pocketsize guide. Critical thinking rubric critical thinking is a habit of mind characterized by the comprehensive exploration of issues, ideas, artifacts, and events before accepting or. Analyze driving question and begin inquiry fsees only superficial aspects of, or one point of view on, the driving question.
Powell carolina tobacco harvester free pdf file sharing. Critical and creative thinking in the higher education. Microsoft word links for critical thinking rubrics. The critical thinking competency standards articulated in this guide serve as a resource for teachers, curriculum designers, administrators and accrediting bodies. Basic counseling skills rubric university of kentucky. Critical thinking can be demonstrated in assignments that require students to complete analyses of text, data, or issues. Demonstrate competent use of language in a variety of settings. Critical thinking is the process of making purposeful, reflective and fairminded judgments about what to believe or what to do. The purpose of this study is to identify critical thinking com ponents of online discussion and how to use them in evaluation rubrics that 1 guide the structure and content of these discus sions. Rubric for undergraduate thesis evaluation 837805 red. Portland state university studies program holistic critical thinking rubric inquiry and critical thinking rubric students will learn various modes of inquiry through interdisciplinary curriculaproblem posing, investigating, conceptualizingin order to become active, selfmotivated, and empowered learners. The value rubrics were developed by teams of faculty experts. The reading prompt and scoring rubric focus students attention on the development of their critical thinking skills.
80 191 915 620 819 1545 585 1557 826 555 293 1108 960 1059 1275 1550 722 919 996 1366 956 477 120 243 1227 1131 765 445 1339